Science or Fiction, July 2012

About once a month, I get together with several friends and colleagues for the Lexington Skeptics meetup for dinner and conversation. The topics tend to run from recent science discoveries, pseudoscience controversies, scams and flim flam. Discussion sometimes ranges into religion and politics, but is always polite.

Many people find their way to “scientific skepticism” by way of podcasts like The Skeptic’s Guide to the Universe (SGU) and one of my favorite parts of the SGU podcast (which you should be listening to) is the Science or Fiction segment.

Briefly, the host, Steve Novella asks the co-hosts and guests to pick one fake story from a set of three or four. The others are true, at least in a technical sense. If a true story is turned into a false one and the detail changed is a number, the number is changed to an unreasonably high or low number.

Tonight’s Science or Fiction was a fun one, and led to a discussion of why certain things were possible or not. Read over the following three items, try to pick out the fictional news piece and then click through (or just don’t scroll past the science cat).

  1. Milk thistle slowed the progression of Hepatitis C infection in a placebo controlled clinical trial.
  2. Bacteria are being used to grow spider silk with the tensile strength of black widow spider silk.
  3. Injuries from laser hair removal have led to calls for regulation in Britain.

Continue reading